Why do people forget… that there is a cave that swallowed a man… and never gave him back? It was November, 2009. John Edward Jones, a young father, decided to explore Nutty Putty Cave in Utah. But Nutty Putty was no ordinary cave. It was a maze of twisting, suffocating passages—so narrow they could crush a grown man. John crawled into one, a tunnel locals called The Birth Canal. Eighteen inches wide. Barely enough for breath. But he went headfirst. Wrong move. Halfway through, he realized he could not turn back. His chest was pressed flat against rock. His arms pinned tight. The earth itself… was squeezing the life out of him. For hours, he hung upside down, fighting for air. Rescuers swarmed the site—ropes, pulleys, drills—hundreds of people desperate to pull him free. But the rock shifted. The equipment failed. Every attempt only made it worse. John could hear them. He could hear his family waiting above. He prayed. He begged. He cried for air. And then… silence. After twenty-seven hours, Nutty Putty claimed him forever. The cave was sealed, with John still inside. And his grave… is now the rock itself. So I ask you again— Would you dare enter the cave… that never gave him back?